What is concierge medicine? It is primary care you pay for through a membership. You pay the practice a monthly or yearly fee, and in return the doctor keeps a much smaller patient list, which buys you longer visits, same-day or next-day appointments and a direct line by phone or email. Many concierge practices still bill your insurance as well.
Quick answer: Concierge medicine charges a membership fee for more time and easier access to one doctor. In a federal survey, concierge physicians cut their patient lists from about 2,700 to about 500. Most still bill insurance for visits. Direct primary care is a cousin that skips insurance and covers most primary care for a flat fee. Neither replaces health insurance for hospital, specialist or emergency care.

What is concierge medicine, and how does it work?
The whole model rests on one trade. A doctor agrees to care for far fewer people, and those people pay a fee that makes up the lost income.
The best numbers on how far the lists shrink still come from the federal government. When the Government Accountability Office surveyed concierge physicians in 2004, the doctors had averaged 2,716 patients before converting and about 491 afterward. The number of patients they saw on a typical day fell from 26 to 10. That arithmetic is the product. Fewer patients per day means more minutes per patient.
What the fee buys varies by practice, but the same features keep showing up. In the GAO survey the most common were same-day or next-day appointments for non-urgent problems, 24-hour phone access and a yearly preventive exam. A 2010 report for the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), based on interviews with concierge doctors, added longer visits of about half an hour, annual physicals of an hour or more, the doctor’s own cell number and email, and help coordinating specialist care. Cleveland Clinic, which runs its own concierge program, describes the same list in 2025 and adds a point people often miss: the membership typically does not cover specialists, hospital stays or emergency care.
The model is not new. The MedPAC report counted at least 756 retainer-based physicians in 2009, up from 146 in the 2005 GAO report, spread across all but 11 states, and about three in five practiced solo. Most of the doctors in the GAO survey were internists or family physicians.
The MedPAC authors also sorted concierge practices into three rough types, which is useful when you are comparing options:
- Fee for extra services: the membership pays for access and time, and visits are still billed to insurance
- Fee for care: the membership pays for the primary care itself, and insurance is not billed
- Hybrid: some of each
That second type is what most people now call direct primary care.
What is direct primary care?
Direct primary care, or DPC, is a membership practice that does not bill insurance at all. The American Academy of Family Physicians describes it as an alternative to fee-for-service insurance billing, with a monthly, quarterly or yearly fee that covers all or most primary care, including clinical and laboratory services, care coordination and ongoing management of chronic conditions.
The AAFP says DPC practices typically do not accept insurance or take part in government programs. They live on membership fees. Because the fee does not cover emergencies or hospital care, DPC practices often suggest patients carry a high-deductible “wraparound” insurance policy for the big, unpredictable costs.
DPC is usually pitched at a wider range of incomes than traditional concierge care. A Vermont TV station, WCAX, reported in April 2026 that the model is sometimes called “blue-collar concierge.” The AAFP lists an average DPC panel of 504 patients in 2025 and says about 99 percent of DPC practices offer same-day appointments.
What is the difference between concierge medicine and direct primary care?
The short version: concierge medicine usually sits on top of insurance, and direct primary care usually replaces insurance for primary care only. The lines blur. Plenty of practices mix the two. Here is how the AAFP and the federal reports draw the differences.
| Concierge medicine | Direct primary care | Traditional primary care | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you pay | Membership fee, often plus insurance billing for visits | Membership fee only, no insurance billing | Insurance, copays and deductibles |
| What the fee covers | Access, time, an in-depth yearly exam | All or most primary care services | No fee |
| Patients per doctor | About 491 on average in the GAO survey | About 504 on average (AAFP, 2025) | Typically more than 2,000 |
| Medicare | Many participate and bill Medicare | Typically do not take government programs | Billed like other insurance |
| Still need insurance? | Yes | Yes, for hospital, specialist and emergency care | Yes |
The AAFP also notes a difference in cost and audience. It describes DPC fees as typically low and monthly, and concierge contracts as higher and aimed more at higher-income patients. We are not listing fees here because they vary too widely to be useful, and the only number that matters is the one a specific practice quotes you in writing.
Do concierge doctors take insurance?
Most do. In the GAO survey, 85 of the 112 practicing concierge physicians billed patients’ health insurance for covered services, and 79 of those billed Medicare. About a quarter billed no insurer at all, and about a fifth had formally opted out of Medicare.
The MedPAC interviews show how the model decides the answer. All the “fee for extra services” practices took Medicare, and all but one took private insurance. None of the “fee for care” practices accepted private insurance, and only one of six took Medicare.
Medicare adds a rule worth knowing. A doctor who participates in Medicare cannot charge a membership fee for services Medicare already covers. The GAO report describes a 2004 alert from the HHS Office of Inspector General warning physicians about exactly that. In practice, a concierge doctor who bills Medicare has to tie the fee to things Medicare does not pay for, such as round-the-clock phone access or an extended wellness exam. If you are on Medicare, ask the practice what the fee covers in writing.
Does concierge medicine take insurance, or replace it?
It never replaces it. This is the mistake that costs people money.
A membership covers your relationship with one primary care practice. It does not pay for an MRI, a specialist, surgery, an ambulance or a night in the hospital. Cleveland Clinic says plainly that the fee typically does not cover those things, and the AAFP notes that even DPC practices, which cover the most inside the fee, tell patients to keep coverage for emergencies. Insurance is still the thing that protects you from a catastrophic bill.
The tax picture changed this year. Under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill Act, signed in July 2025, and IRS Notice 2026-5, starting in 2026 people can enroll in a qualifying direct primary care arrangement without losing eligibility for a health savings account, and can pay the fee from the HSA. The conditions are narrow. The arrangement must charge only a fixed periodic fee under a monthly cap, cover primary care only and be provided by a physician in family, internal, geriatric or pediatric medicine, or by a nurse practitioner, clinical nurse specialist or physician assistant. Many concierge memberships will not fit those rules. Check with the practice and your HSA administrator before assuming yours does.
Separately, some practices note that lab work and specific services may be reimbursable through insurance, an HSA or an FSA even when the membership itself is not. Ask for itemized receipts, sometimes called superbills, so you can submit them.
Is concierge medicine worth it?
For some people, clearly. For many, no. The research does not settle it either way.
The study most often quoted in favor is a 2012 paper in the American Journal of Managed Care by Klemes and colleagues. It compared hospital use among members of MDVIP, a national concierge network, with non-members in five states from 2006 to 2010, and found members were hospitalized 42 to 62 percent less often depending on the year. Those are large numbers. The study was also observational, several authors were MDVIP employees or affiliated physicians, and the authors themselves say members may differ from non-members in health attitudes and baseline health. People who pay extra for preventive care are probably healthier and more engaged to begin with.
An independent actuarial study of DPC came from Milliman for the Society of Actuaries in 2020. It followed about 900 employees in a DPC option and about 1,100 in a traditional plan at one employer for two years. After adjusting for health status, the DPC group used fewer services, mainly fewer emergency department visits. But the employer’s net costs came out about 1.3 percent higher at the midpoint estimate, partly because it paid the membership fees and waived deductibles. Using less care did not automatically mean spending less money.
So “worth it” comes down to how you use primary care. Our honest read:
- It tends to make sense if you have a chronic condition that needs regular adjustment, you are managing care for an aging parent, you have been waiting weeks for appointments, or you want long visits to work through a complicated history.
- It is probably not worth it if you are healthy, see a doctor once a year for a checkup and are happy with that visit. You would be paying for access you will not use.
- It is never worth it if paying the fee means dropping your health insurance.
There is also a fair criticism that the model does not answer. Cleveland Clinic notes that critics worry about doctors serving fewer patients during a projected physician shortage. When one doctor goes from 2,700 patients to 500, the other 2,200 have to find care somewhere. Nobody has a clean solution to that, including us.
One more practical test. If you keep landing in urgent care with colds and infections because you cannot get in to see your own doctor, the access problem may be real, but so might the reasons you keep getting sick. Our post on why you keep getting sick covers the common causes worth checking first.
Myth: Concierge medicine means you no longer need health insurance.
Fact: Memberships generally do not cover specialists, hospital stays or emergencies. Even direct primary care practices advise patients to keep coverage for those.
Myth: Concierge doctors do not take insurance.
Fact: In the GAO survey, about three-quarters of concierge physicians billed health insurance, and most of those billed Medicare.
Myth: Concierge medicine is only for the wealthy.
Fact: Traditional concierge care does skew toward higher-income patients, according to the AAFP, but direct primary care was built for a broader range of incomes.
What to ask before you join
Membership contracts differ more than the marketing does. Before you sign, get clear answers to these:
- What exactly does the fee include, and what is billed separately?
- Does the practice bill my insurance or Medicare for visits?
- How many patients does each clinician carry?
- How fast are appointments, and who answers after hours?
- Are labs included, discounted or billed to insurance?
- Can I cancel, and is any part of the fee refundable?
One more: who is the clinician? Concierge practices are run by internists, family physicians and, in Oregon, sometimes naturopathic doctors, who are licensed here as primary care providers. That changes the style of care more than the payment model does. If you are weighing that choice, our comparison of a naturopathic doctor versus primary care doctor goes through the differences in training and approach.
Frequently asked questions
Is concierge medicine the same as direct primary care?
Not quite. Both charge a membership fee and keep patient lists small. Concierge practices usually still bill insurance for visits, and the fee pays for extra access and time. Direct primary care practices usually do not bill insurance at all, and the fee covers all or most primary care, according to the American Academy of Family Physicians. Some practices mix the two, so read the contract.
Does Medicare cover concierge medicine?
Medicare does not pay the membership fee. Many concierge doctors do bill Medicare for covered visits and services, though. Medicare-participating doctors cannot charge the fee for services Medicare already covers, a point the HHS Office of Inspector General stressed in a 2004 alert. Some concierge doctors opt out of Medicare entirely. Ask the practice which approach it uses before you join.
Can I use my HSA for concierge medicine?
Sometimes, and the rules just changed. From 2026, IRS Notice 2026-5 lets people with HSAs enroll in and pay for qualifying direct primary care arrangements, but only if the fee is fixed, under a monthly cap, covers primary care only and is provided by specific types of clinicians. Many concierge memberships will not qualify. Labs and individual services may still be HSA or FSA eligible. Check with your plan administrator.
Do I still need health insurance with concierge medicine?
Yes. A concierge or direct primary care membership covers your primary care relationship, not hospital stays, surgery, specialists, imaging or emergency care. Cleveland Clinic notes that membership fees typically exclude those, and the AAFP says DPC practices often recommend a high-deductible wraparound policy for emergencies. Dropping insurance to pay for a membership leaves you exposed to the bills that cause the most financial harm.
Who benefits most from concierge medicine?
People who use primary care often and feel shortchanged by short visits. That includes people managing chronic conditions, those coordinating care for a parent, people with complicated histories and anyone who has waited weeks to be seen. Healthy people who need one checkup a year usually get less value, because the fee mostly buys access. Price matters too, so compare what a practice includes against what you would actually use.
If the idea of longer visits and a direct line to your doctor appeals to you, a short conversation will tell you more than any article. Dr. Drew Collins, ND, at Proactive Choice offers monthly and annual memberships with longer visits, same or next-day scheduling, phone, email and virtual access, and an in-depth yearly lab review, plus standard visits for people who only need occasional care. You can see what is included on our page about concierge medicine in Bend, or book a free 15-minute call at +1 (858) 333-5196.
Sources
- US Government Accountability Office. Physician Services: Concierge Care Characteristics and Considerations for Medicare (GAO-05-929), 2005.
- Hargrave E, et al. Retainer-Based Physicians: Characteristics, Impact, and Policy Considerations. Report to the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, 2010.
- American Academy of Family Physicians. Direct primary care.
- Cleveland Clinic Health Essentials. Concierge medicine, 2025.
- Internal Revenue Service. Notice 2026-5: Expanded availability of health savings accounts under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill Act.
- Klemes A, et al. Personalized preventive care leads to significant reductions in hospital utilization. American Journal of Managed Care, 2012.
- Milliman. What our study says about direct primary care (Society of Actuaries research report), 2020.
- WCAX. Some Vermont doctors embrace the new direct primary care model, April 2026.
Medically reviewed content from Proactive Choice. This article is for education and is not a diagnosis. Talk with a licensed clinician about your own symptoms and treatment options.
Want to talk this through for your own health? Book a visit with Dr. Drew Collins, ND at 601 NW Harmon Blvd in Bend, or call (858) 333-5196.